Hollow or Solid Metal Dice – Which Type Is Right for You? – Mackan's Thoughts

Metal dice have long been a divisive topic among D&D and TTRPG players. Some players swear by them and wouldn't use anything else, while others prefer lighter or softer materials.

Fans of metal dice often praise their weight, solid feel, and premium quality, claiming they create a completely different experience compared to standard plastic dice. Those who prefer lighter materials, however, point out that the extra weight can make metal dice feel a bit clunky and less suitable for quick or discreet rolls.

There are two main types of metal dice: solid and hollow.

So, which one is better? The simple answer is that it depends on your personal preferences. Let's take a look at the biggest differences.

Solid Metal Dice – Maximum Weight and a Premium Feel

Solid metal dice are exactly what they sound like—cast entirely from metal. The result is a heavy, substantial dice set that feels incredibly satisfying every time you roll.

Benefits of Solid Metal Dice

• A satisfying weight that feels premium in your hand.

• Extremely durable and built to last.

• A deep, distinctive sound when rolling.

• Classic designs with crisp, sharp details.

For many players, the weight is a huge part of the experience. Rolling a natural 20 with a hefty metal dice set simply feels more satisfying when the stakes are high.

A great roll can leave a lasting impression on the game—and sometimes on your table as well! That's why we always recommend using a dice tray or dice mat when rolling solid metal dice.

Browse our selection of Solid Metal Dice: Solid - Diceshop.se

Browse our Dice Trays & Mats: Dice Mats - Diceshop.se

Hollow Metal Dice – The Same Premium Feel, Much Less Weight

Hollow metal dice have become increasingly popular in recent years. By creating the dice with an empty interior, manufacturers retain the look and feel of metal while dramatically reducing the weight. They also produce a beautiful, almost musical chime when rolled together.

The lighter weight makes them more comfortable and makes discreet rolling much easier.

Benefits of Hollow Metal Dice

• Significantly lighter than solid metal dice.
• Less likely to require a dice tray or mat.
• A unique, bright, bell-like sound when rolled.
• Allows for incredibly intricate designs featuring dragons, cut-out patterns, and fantasy-inspired artwork.

Because they're much lighter, many players find hollow metal dice easier and more enjoyable to roll while still providing that premium metal experience.

How Does the Weight Affect Gameplay?

You'll notice the difference the moment you pick them up.

Solid Metal Dice

• Heavier rolls.
• Louder impact.
• A robust, substantial feel.

Hollow Metal Dice

• Easier to throw.
• Softer landings.
• A distinctive "ping" that many players and collectors absolutely love.

Neither type is inherently more balanced or fair than the other when manufactured correctly. Your choice ultimately comes down to feel, weight, and personal preference.

So, Which Should You Choose?

Choose Solid Metal Dice if you:

• Love the feel of heavy dice.
• Want every roll to have real presence.
• Appreciate classic, timeless metal designs.

Choose Hollow Metal Dice if you:

• Want the premium feel of metal without the extra weight.
• Enjoy unique and intricate designs.
• Want to reduce the risk of damaging your gaming table.
• Love the distinctive ringing sound they make.

Mackan Recommends

Both hollow and solid metal dice offer a far more luxurious experience than standard plastic dice. The biggest differences come down to weight, sound, and design.

Personally, I usually use plastic or hollow metal dice when I'm the Dungeon Master. They're easier to roll quickly and discreetly behind the screen.

When I'm playing a character, however, I almost always reach for solid metal dice. I love their weight, the substantial feel, and the classic aesthetic that many metal dice sets offer.

One of my personal favorites has long been Long Scale—an elegant metal dice set that still ranks among the most beautiful dice we carry.

Check out Long Scale here: Long Scale - Diceshop.se

No matter which style you choose, you'll find a wide selection of metal dice at Diceshop.se—from classic solid designs to intricate hollow masterpieces made for players who want every dice roll to feel a little more legendary.

The choice is yours :)

/Mackan